I went to a party on the fourth of July. I could give a shit about the holiday, but the party was being hosted by a respected colleague of one of my best friends, with whom I was staying in Chicago at the time. Of course, the party was way out in the suburbs. These folks were white, rich, and, as I was warned along the ride through multiple toll booths and corn fields, voted for Trump. Indiana looked exactly how I’d expected Indiana to look.
We arrived to a gated community where the houses were almost on top of each other, so crowded were they inside their fencing. There was remarkably little lawn or garden space, though these folks clearly adored their home improvements. There was some kind of water somewhere, maybe a man-made lake, which I guess made the neighborliness worth it to folks. Notably few of the houses looked the same, though most could have easily housed multiple families. The one we arrived to had two BMW motorcycles in the garage and a giant hole in the backyard that the owners kept apologizing for. The pandemic had stalled their pool, unfortunately for everyone. Not thirty feet away from our hosts’ hole though was the neighbors’ pool, which we were welcome to if we’d like. It was full of exactly the folks you expect. At some point I was drunkenly ushered into the neighbors’ home and found myself asking someone’s grandmother, “Why am I in this house?” Capitalists will show off their homes to literally anyone.
I was by far the most alternative person between these two backyards, and while I wasn’t particularly welcomed, I wasn’t directly made to feel unwelcome either. Thank goodness for our gracious hosts, who genuinely did seem delighted to have us. I can honestly say I enjoyed their company as well–it was a party, after all. I was determined to have fun, even if it meant being alone with my best friend on the dance floor, ignoring a lot of critical eyes, and singing along to classic rock. Of course this all explains why, later that night, I was still drunk enough to get out of the car and dance on the pavement while we were stopped in massive tollbooth lines headed back into Chicago. There was a lot of honking, and some cheering, also a lot of people pretending not to notice, which seemed weird. Between the two tollbooths I made friends though, and was even offered a shot. It was maybe 10PM: Chicago never lets me down.
A couple of hours before this hilarious and harmless yet disorderly conduct, the man of the house, an older Gen Xer who I’ll call Todd, had brought out his best tequila for us. The vocal admiration between my dear friend and this man had begun quite professionally, almost bashfully, upon our arrival. I was even lucky enough to be pulled aside by Todd and told of my friends’ distinct ability in her field; further, that she was far too humble. (The latter was news to me like, fifteen years ago.) As the afternoon waned, the two honorable colleagues were gradually, amusingly, becoming a sappy mess. Eventually, tequila toasts were in order.
It was over these drinks that it was brought to my attention, not for the first time, that the progeny of our hostess, let’s call her Becky, was seventeen, living under their roof, and had announced a pronoun preference that Becky wasn’t interested in. “It’s so silly, he wants to be called ‘they’!” She proclaimed, “Is ‘she’ next?” I found it charmingly idiotic that Becky would think for a second that I would be sympathetic to her case, yet here she was, looking at me with the conspiratorial eye roll of “you get it”. Todd had casually brought it up to me much earlier, equally more soberly, and seemed to genuinely seek my opinion. My sweet friend, having too-often witnessed my irascibility in our younger years, overheard Todd’s words and expertly steered us toward safety. I certainly appreciated her, but later found myself, having been alerted by Todd so much earlier, glad to be unruffled by Becky’s fresh outburst. Now, confused by my head-shaking denial of her truth, Becky was starting to wonder about the whole thing. “What does it even mean?” she whined. There was no steering the conversation at this point, try as anyone might. I realized, consciously working not to judge Becky too harshly, that it was now or never.
Todd, for his part, was watching me closely. It seemed he had been waiting for this, knowing his wife as he did. For the record these two were fabulously enamored with each other; I had never seen a poster-sized wedding portrait above a headboard before. To some degree they may still have been in the honeymoon phase, and it was cute as hell. We were discussing a child Todd had known only a few years, but clearly cared for. Although he talked around it stiffly, it was obvious that the new step-dad was feeling deeply unqualified right then. Todd was honestly flummoxed. Becky, however, was at her wit’s end. She ranted some and then looked to the rest of us for approval, finding little support. “All teenagers are annoying,” I said. Becky, reaching, took this as vindication. Todd knew better: he physically leaned in. I was beginning to understand what drove my friend in her loyalty to him. This was my moment.
Across the patio table and an empty bottle of mezcal, I looked into the eyes of this pampered pair and said, more quietly now, “Do you love this kid?” Becky rolled her eyes again, feeding into her own exasperation, as Todd said clearly, “Yeah, of course.” This got his wife’s attention–you really can’t blame her for being slow on the uptake after however many shots–she was trying now. I had both of them trained on me as I said, as clearly as I could, “Then this is not the hill you want to die on.” I could see the reflection of a mic-drop in Todd’s eyes. Gratified, I looked to Becky, who hadn’t heard me. She huffed as I continued, “It doesn’t matter to you half as much as it matters to them, and it’s not hard.” Then I swung for the fences: I gestured around us, to their future pool and back toward their stupidly large house. “I refuse to believe that people who have come as far as you, are this successful, and happy,” I let my voice trail off as Becky beamed, “I refuse to believe the people I’ve met here today aren’t intelligent enough to change their language for somebody they love.”
Ultimately, both parents admitted that they didn’t want to lose this kid’s trust over something as trivial as grammar. That doesn’t mean they didn’t use masculine pronouns the entire time, or that they’ll adjust at all. It also doesn’t mean that things will necessarily get easier for any member of that family. All I can share is that it seems if one pays attention, they might seize many moments, strange and sundry, to foster revolution. And on that day, despite our differences, a good time was had by all.